Shavua tov and broken promises
Following the elections in Israel and the United States, BGU President Daniel Chamovitz reflects on the unpredictability of political outcomes, emphasizing that effective leadership should be guided by values, integrity, and adaptability rather than promises about an uncertain future. He reaffirms BGU’s commitment to fostering a university community where people with differing political views can continue to learn, collaborate, and build a shared future.
Dear Friends,
A little over a week ago, just before Israel's elections, I wrote you and our community:
"On Wednesday we return to campus, with some happy, some disappointed, some confused, but we remain a campus community devoted to the future of the Negev and Israel. Learning to live with political disagreement is not just a matter of civility. It is essential if we are ever going to agree on the fundamental rules of our democracy."
Following the elections in both Israel and the United States, those words seem even more poignant. Some of us are happy, others disappointed, and many are confused, particularly about what the results will mean for Israel's future.
There are more than enough pundits offering their analyses and predictions. I won't add mine. Instead, I find myself returning to two thoughts about leadership, uncertainty, and the limits of our ability to predict the future.
The first is something I wrote about in August in my Substack essay, What Politicians Owe Us Instead of Promises. I argued that we should demand less in the way of promises from our leaders and more in the way of values. Promises are easy to make when the future is unknown. And indeed, we are seeing how promises made during an election campaign can become obstacles when the hard work of forming a governing coalition begins. What matters is not whether leaders can fulfill every promise, but how they respond when reality turns out differently from what anyone anticipated.
I confront this regularly as President of BGU. Faculty and staff understandably want assurances about budgets, positions, and institutional priorities. But I have learned that promising specific outcomes, when circumstances can change overnight, is neither honest nor responsible. What I can offer is a clear sense of where I intend to lead, the values that guide my decisions, and a willingness to acknowledge what I don't know. I can promise to lead with integrity, to listen, and to put the university's mission above personal or political considerations. I cannot promise that every decision will be popular, or even that every decision will turn out to be right.
My second thought takes me back almost four decades.
Following Israel's 1988 elections, many of us were shocked by the dramatic rise of Shas. I was a young graduate student at the Hebrew University, and I remember standing in line for coffee with Prof. Moshe Soller z"l, a world-renowned geneticist and fellow American immigrant. While the rest of us were busy lamenting the election results, Moshe offered a characteristically calm observation:
"You know, Danny, people rarely get what they truly want, and we have no idea how this will play out."
I have never forgotten those words.
Four years later, the political landscape had shifted in ways few of us could have imagined. Shas, whose rise had so troubled us in 1988, became part of the coalition that enabled Yitzhak Rabin to form his government in 1992. That was certainly not what I had anticipated in 1988, nor, I suspect, what most Shas voters had envisioned.
Moshe wasn't predicting the future. He was reminding us of the folly of believing that we could.
There is a connection between these two thoughts. We cannot control the future, and we are remarkably poor at predicting it. But we can control the principles by which we respond to it.
That is as true for the leadership of a university as it is for the leadership of a country. At BGU, our responsibility is not to ensure that everyone agrees, nor to promise that the years ahead will be easy. It is to preserve a community in which people with profoundly different views can continue to learn, discover, argue, and build together.
That is where I intend to keep my focus.
Shavua tov,
Danny